Pune: Rs 10 Lakh Demand Was a Mistake, Says Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital

Pune, 7th April 2025: Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital has admitted that a doctor on its staff had asked for a ₹10 lakh deposit for the treatment of Tanisha Bhise, who later died during childbirth. Her family, unable to meet the demand, shifted her to another hospital where she gave birth to twins but tragically passed away. The incident has sparked public outrage and raised serious questions about hospital practices.

At a press conference on Monday, Dr. Dhananjay Kelkar, a senior official of the hospital, confirmed that the deposit demand was made—calling it a “rare mistake” by Dr. Sushrut Ghaisas, who has since resigned.

On Dr. Ghaisas’ Resignation: Dr. Ghaisas, an honorary gynecologist and obstetrician associated with the hospital for over a decade, is not a full-time employee but a consultant. “Due to threats, intense criticism on social media, and growing public pressure, Dr. Ghaisas resigned. The stress had begun affecting his focus and sleep, potentially impacting patient care. He stepped down in the interest of his family and patients,” Dr. Kelkar said.

Deposit Demand in Bhise Case: Dr. Kelkar stated, “Our hospital does not have a policy of demanding deposits. We provide cost estimates, which do not include deposits. However, on that day, for reasons unclear, Dr. Ghaisas wrote ₹10 lakh in the deposit box. That’s true. But you can ask any doctor here — we never ask for deposits. I’ve performed countless surgeries and never made such a demand.”

Change in Hospital Policy: The hospital acknowledged that it previously had an internal policy of requesting advance deposits for high-cost cases (₹5–10 lakh), but this policy has been officially discontinued in recent days. The hospital also emphasized that no deposits are collected from financially weak patients.

Training for Hospital Staff: Admitting that a heavy workload can sometimes affect the empathy shown by staff, Dr. Kelkar said the hospital will soon roll out training programs to improve communication, sensitivity, and patient interaction.

Data Privacy and Tax Compliance: Dr. Kelkar also clarified that no confidential patient data was leaked to the media. Regarding financial matters, he said all hospital taxes are paid as per court directives and legal procedures.